When I was in middle school, I decided my mom and dad could use some parenting advice. So I sat them down and offered my two cents on how they could improve and better meet my lofty standards of parenthood. I’m sure they were grateful for my wisdom! They handled it remarkably well and promised to keep my suggestions in mind.
I look back on that moment now and cringe! I’m reminded of a Mark Twain quote about how foolish he thought his father was when he was a teenager, and how amazed he was by how much the old man seemed to have learned by the time he became an adult. Funny how that works. Sometimes it takes maturity to recognize that the people who came before us might actually have something to teach us.
I think that’s a helpful place to begin when considering the relationship between our Catholic faith and the way we vote. The Church has been wrestling with questions of right and wrong, human dignity, marriage, family, and our responsibilities to each other for 2,000 years. Drawing on Scripture, the teaching of Christ, and the experience of generations of Christians, she offers a depth of moral wisdom that no individual or political party can match. And we believe Christ has given his Church the Holy Spirit to guide her in faithfully teaching the truth about faith and morals.
That doesn’t mean the Church should wade into every issue that politics poses or that every statement made by a Church leader is infallible. But it does mean we should approach her moral teaching with humility rather than assuming we know better simply because we disagree.
This brings us to today’s Gospel, where Jesus tells us to “repay to Caesar what belongs to Caesar and to God what belongs to God.” We have responsibilities as citizens, and voting is one of them. But we are also citizens of heaven, and our highest allegiance belongs to God. So when those responsibilities come together, we need to ask ourselves: Am I allowing my faith to shape my political decisions, or am I allowing my political opinions to rule my faith?
That’s an important distinction in our time. Every election brings fierce arguments, dire warnings, and accusations of treachery. Political parties try to convince us that their candidates can fix all our problems and the other side threatens everything we hold dear. These divisions have found their way into families, friendships, and even our parish communities.
It can be tempting to approach our faith the same way. We choose our candidate, pick our party, and decide which issues matter most. Then we want the Church to agree with us, embracing the teachings that support our positions while setting aside those that challenge them.
But that’s not how this works. We should not ask the Church to validate the political choices we’ve already made. We must allow her teachings to challenge, inform, and sometimes correct those choices. If we believe Jesus Christ is the way, the truth, and the life, then his truth must be allowed to challenge us, even when it makes us uncomfortable or conflicts with our political loyalties.
So, how do we put that into practice when we vote?
First, recognize that voting is a moral responsibility, not simply a personal preference. We’re not just choosing the candidate we like best or the person who promises to make our lives easier. Our decisions help determine how society treats others, especially the vulnerable and those unable to defend themselves.
Second, recognize that not all issues carry the same moral weight. Some actions are intrinsically evil and can never be justified, regardless of intentions or circumstances. The direct taking of innocent human life is one of them. That is why protecting unborn children deserves particular moral seriousness in our voting decisions. Abortion is not merely a political disagreement; it concerns whether the most vulnerable members of the human family will be protected and their most basic right…the right to life…respected.
Our bishops identify this as a preeminent priority because without life, none of our other rights matter. The fact that all the Missouri bishops have endorsed Amendment 3 on the upcoming ballot should lead us to take their teaching and recommendation seriously as we prepare to vote in a couple weeks. Of course, our commitment to life cannot stop there. We must also build a culture in which every person’s dignity is recognized and vulnerable people receive practical support.
Third, form your conscience rather than simply following your feelings or political instincts. Saying, “I voted according to my conscience,” isn’t enough. Conscience is not simply whatever we happen to think is right. We must form it through prayer, Scripture, Church teaching, reason, and an honest examination of the facts. That means learning what candidates actually believe, considering the likely consequences of their policies, and being willing to reconsider our assumptions.
Finally, never confuse our Catholic faith with a political party. Our faith must remain free to challenge any party or platform when its positions or actions conflict with human dignity and the common good.
As your priest, I have a responsibility to help you understand what the Church teaches and encourage you to take those teachings seriously. I’m not here to endorse a political party or pretend every difficult decision has an easy answer. But our faith has real consequences for how we vote. We cannot separate what we believe here at Mass from the choices we make when we leave this church.
So, as we prepare to exercise our responsibilities as citizens, let’s begin with humility. Let’s pray for wisdom, study the issues and candidates carefully, and allow God’s truth to challenge us, even when it disrupts the positions we already hold. The goal is not simply to ‘win’. It is to exercise our civic responsibilities in a way that respects every human person’s dignity and advances the common good. We render to Caesar what belongs to Caesar, but we must never forget that everything ultimately belongs to God…including our loyalties, our decisions, and our votes.
May the Lord give us the wisdom to recognize what is true, the courage to stand up for what is right, and the humility to change when we need to change. And may our faith not only guide the way we vote, but shape the way we live, so that we may help build a society reflecting the love, justice, and mercy of Jesus Christ.